A little BMW X-tra X3

 Sept 21 2005


Some things are difficult to compare and the X3 versus X5 debate joins Pelè v Maradona, Pepsi v Coke and curry v Chinese.


The X3 has the same pedigree, the same badge, the hefty price tag and similar looks.
It may share some of the style of its older brother, but it feels and drives like a conventional car and is better looking. But the base model is also nine grand cheaper at around £26,00 which puts it firmly in the slightly more well-heeled 'aspiration wannabe' market.
The compact 4x4 packs blistering performance, particularly in the three liter test model. The six-cylinder powered beast is eye-wateringly quick and will power to 60mph in just eight seconds.
But it is also wallet-wrenchingly thirsty and as the Speedo zips up, the fuel gauge rockets downwards.
It is incredibly refined. The only racket you will hear as you accelerate away is likely to come from the powerful sound system speakers, because the growl of the engine and wind noise are very subdued. Handling is very sharp and there should be no worries about diving into the corners, because body roll and wallowing has been left to the bigger boys.
The test car had a whopping £6,485 worth of extras. Admittedly they were the absolute luxuries, such as a state-of-the-art navigation system. Kit on the entry model includes roof bars, alloy wheels, CD player and six speakers.
You also get a full list of safety equipment, which includes the patented all-wheel xDrive system which feeds power to either axle when it senses danger or wheel spin.
It is not cheap to buy and it is certainly not cheap to run in terms of fuel consumption and emission. BMW claims around 23 mpg, but the onboard computer refused to get above an average of 20.
The two-liter diesel and the soon-to-be-unveiled three-liter diesel will be cheaper and maybe more popular alternatives, the three-liter allowing buyers to keep the big-engine punch and some cash in the wallet.
There have been many critics of the X3, but in some respects - looks and price - it could be a better proposition than big brother.